262 F2d 718 O'Brien v. C Watson
262 F.2d 718
John P. O'BRIEN, Appellant,
Robert C. WATSON, Commissioner of Patents, Appellee.
United States Court of Appeals District of Columbia Circuit.
Argued November 12, 1958.
Decided December 18, 1958.
Mr. William J. Ruano, Pittsburgh, Pa., for appellant.
Mr. George C. Roeming, Atty., U. S. Patent Office, with whom Mr. Clarence W. Moore, Solicitor, U. S. Patent Office, was on the brief, for appellee.
Before FAHY, WASHINGTON and BURGER, Circuit Judges.
This is a patent case, under Section 145 of Title 35 U.S.Code (1952), 35 U.S. C.A. § 145. The Patent Office and District Court both found lack of invention over the prior art. On the record before us, we cannot say that either the Patent Office or the District Court erred. It may well be true, as plaintiff-appellant argues, that he has made a useful contribution to the art of die making. But the essence of any such contribution, as expressed in his brief and argument, is not reflected in the language of his formal claims,1 or in any proof offered to the District Court.
See claims 18 and 19 of patent application filed November 29, 1947, Serial No. 788,835