Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Cal. Unrep. 62

Easterling v. Power

California Supreme Court

Decided June 22, 1857

California Supreme Court · decided 1857-06-22

<p>Appeal — Order Denying New Trial. — The Appellate Court is Reluctant to reverse the denial of a motion for a new trial made on the ground that the findings were contrary to the evidence.</p> <p>Appeal. — An Order Denying a Motion for a New Trial, where the evidence below was without material conflict and the findings by the court were contrary to the weight of it, is not to be sustained.</p>

Decided 1857-06-22

BURNETT, J.

¶1— This cause was tried before the district court, by consent of parties, without a jury. The finding and judgment of the court were for the plaintiffs, and the defendants moved for a new trial upon the ground that the finding was contrary to the evidence. The court overruled the motion for a new trial and the defendants appealed.

¶2It is always with great reluctance that this court will reverse the decision of the court below refusing a new trial upon the ground that the finding of the judge or the verdict of the jury is contrary to the evidence. But in a clear case it is our duty to do so.

¶3In this case we can see no testimony to support th'e finding. The testimony, when carefully compared, does not materially conflict, and the weight of it is clearly with the defendants.

¶4Judgment reversed, cause remanded, and a new trial ordered.

I concur: Murray, C. J.
/1/calunrep/62 · .json · Public domain