Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 E.D. Smith 618

McGlucky v. Bitter

New York Court of Common Pleas

Decided December 15, 1852

New York Court of Common Pleas · decided 1852-12-15

Action in the second district court, for a balance alleged to be due to the plaintiff, for two years’ services as a morocco dresser. The defendant pleaded a denial and set off. A parol agreement was put in evidence, from which it appeared that the plaintiff had been employed for the two years, at a stipulated rate of compensation. The services of the plaintiff were proved. A judgment was entered for him, and the defendant appealed.

Decided 1852-12-15

By the Court. Daly, J.

¶1If the oral agreement was an undertaking on the part of the plaintiff to work for two years, it was within the statute and void. The plaintiff was under no obligation to continue in his employer’s service for that length of time, but was at liberty to leave at any time, and could recover for the value of the service he had rendered. If it was not such an agreement, then it is to be taken as an agreement between the parties fixing the rate of compensation. It was So treated by the justice, and the amount that remained unpaid of the wages thus agreed upon, the plaintiff *619would be entitled to recover. Upon this evidence the defendant could ask no deduction from the plaintiff’s wages, and the justice was right in not allowing it.

¶2Judgment affirmed.

/1/edsmith/618 · .json · Public domain