Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Haw. 40

The King v. Howard

Hawaii Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1851

Hawaii Supreme Court · decided 1851-01-15

The accused was arraigned upon an indictment charging him with assaulting James C. Hadley, in October last, with a sword or cutlass, with intent to murder. It appeared in evidence that the accused being the owner, and Hadley the captain of the lorcha -‘Premier,” fell into a dispute about an item of ten dollars in the Captain’s account, and from words came to blows.

Decided 1851-01-15

Chief Justice Lee

¶1charged the jury that the ground insisted upon by the defence was unsound That no man could ever be justified in using a deadly weapon against another except in the most extreme cases. That it was a mistaken opinion that when one man declined leaving another’s house the owner was justified in attacking him with a deadly weapon. The rule of law, said the court, is, that before assaulting an intruder, the owner or occupant of the house must request him to leave, and allow him a reasonable time to depart, after which, if he refuse to go out, the owner or occupant may use such means to eject him, as are reasonable and necessary. He can only use deadly weapons in defence of himself and f.mily; and that if they found that Howard assaulted Hadley with the intent to murder him, the accused was guilty under the indictment.

¶2The jury failed to find the intent to murder, and returned a veidict of “not guilty under the indictment.”

/1/haw/40 · .json · Public domain