Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Kirby 119

Kibbe v. Kibbe

Connecticut Superior Court

Decided September 15, 1786

Connecticut Superior Court · decided 1786-09-15

This was an action of debt, on a judgment rendered by Ptife Obmd 6Í Common Picas in the county ol ‘BesksiÚYe, and commonwealth of Massachusetts. • The defendant pleaded in abatement, “ That at the time of bringing the action to the Court of Common Pleas, upon which the judgment referred to in the plaintiff’s declaration was rendered, he, the defendant, was an inhabitant of the town of Somers, in the county of Hartford; and that the plaintiff, in said original action, prayed…

Decided 1786-09-15

By the Court.

¶1It appears, by the pleadings, that the defendant was an inhabitant of the state of Connecticut, and was not within the jurisdiction of the Court of Common Pleas for the county of Berkshire, at the time of the pretended service of the writ; therefore, the court had no legal jurisdiction of the cause, and so no action ought to be admitted on said judgment: But full credence ought to be given to judgments of the courts in any of the United States, where both parties are within the jurisdiction of such courts at the time of commencing the suit, and are duly served with the process, and have or might have had a fair trial of the cause; all which, with the original cause of action, ought to appear by the plaintiff’s declaration in action of debt on such judgment.

¶2Dteb, J., said further,— That the original action was upon a covenant real, and locally annexed where the lands lie; and the judgment being by default, this court never could take cognizance of or examine into the justice of the cause; therefore, cannot enforce the judgment on which this action is brought.

¶3Note.— Judge Ellsworth excused himself from giving an opinion in this case, having formerly been of counsel.

¶4The two preceding cases were adjudged the last term.

/1/kirby/119 · .json · Public domain