Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Kirby 404

Place v. Lyon

Connecticut Superior Court

Decided March 15, 1788

Connecticut Superior Court · decided 1788-03-15

Error from a judgment in the Court of Common Pleas. The original action was on a note, for one hundred Spanish-milled dollars, with interest, dated 9th March, 1785. The defendant pleaded to the jurisdiction — That the parties, at the impetration of the writ, were both inhabitants of the state of Rhode Island; and that the defendant was only occasionally in this state at the time when the writ was served;— but the plea was overruled.

Upon both points the judgment was affirmed · Decided 1788-03-15

By the whole Court.

¶1As to the plea in abatement — it was not sufficient: — The action being for a debt, which depended not on local laws for its creation, was in its nature transitory, and followed the person of the debtor; and citizens of any other of the United States have, by the articles of the confederation, the same right to sue here as citizens of this state. If the suit, as suggested, was vexatious, the defendant has his remedy; but whether it was so or not, was not triable upon his plea of abatement.

¶2As to the plea in bar -— it appears that the contract was for silver money, and specifically for dollars; a tender of bills, therefore, was not a fulfilment. The statute declaring the bills a tender, was subsequent to this contract, and could not have a retrospective operation to vary and defeat it, however it might affect those made after the law was promulgated. It is a fundamental principle of jurisprudence, that ece post facto laws, declaring criminal what was not so when the facts were done, or impeaching contracts lawfully made, are inoperative; which principle a court of justice is' not at liberty to depart from, especially to give efficacy to the institutions of a foreign jurisdiction.

/1/kirby/404 · .json · Public domain