Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Mann. Unrep. Cas. 141

State v. Going

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided July 1, 1880

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1880-07-01

<p>The weight of the presumption, arising from the possession of goods recently stolen without reasonably accounting for such possession, is lessened in proportion to the length of time that has elapsed since the larceny.</p>

Decided 1880-07-01

De Blanc, J.

¶1The defendant was tried for and convicted of larceny. He applied for a new trial in vain, and was sentenced and has appealed.

¶2His counsel asked the district judge to charge the jury “that under the law the accused is required to account for stolen goods found in his possession, only when they have been recently stolen.”

¶3The judge refused to charge in those words, but charged as follows :—

“ A presumption of the guilt of the accused may be drawn from his possession of goods or property shewn to have been recently stolen unless he gives a reasonable account of his possession, but the weight of this presumption is lessened in proportion to the length of time which has elapsed since the goods or property were stolen, and the time they were found in the possession of the accused, and that such a possession at a considerable time from the period of the larceny, affords a very weak if any presumption at all, of the guilt of the accused.” This was substantially correct.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/1/mannunrepcas/141 · .json · Public domain