Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Mann. Unrep. Cas. 303

State v. Byrd

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided July 1, 1880

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1880-07-01

<p>If the record fails to shew that the prisoner was present in court when the verdict of the jury was rendered, the omission vitiates the trial.</p>

Decided 1880-07-01

Egan, J.

¶1The accused was indicted for murder and found guilty and sentenced for manslaughter.

¶2*304Tlie record fails to show that the accused was present in court when the verdict against them was rendered and returned.

¶3This is fatal. Great negligence and looseness seems to prevail in either the minutes, or the conduct of trials in criminal, and especially capital, cases.

¶4Judgment reversed, and new trial ordered.

/1/mannunrepcas/303 · .json · Public domain