Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Miss. Dec. 50

Walker v. Saunders

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided May 11, 1885

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1885-05-11

Appellant as administrator of the estate of Miss Mattie B. Moore filed his petition to sell certain real estate in the town of Aberdeen to which Miss Mattie B. Moore had title- at her death, to pay debts of deceased.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1911

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and remanded, · Decided 1885-05-11

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Opinion.

Campbell, J. :

¶2The evidence introduced without objection on the hearing in the court below strongly suggests that the object of L. B. Moore in causing the title of the land he paid for to be conveyed to his sister was to defraud his creditors, and if this was his object, no trust resulted to him, because the courts will not interfere in behalf of one who has acted in violation of law. He will be left in the position in which he placed himself, and cannot have any aid to relieve him from the legal consequence of his own act. 1 Perry on Trusts, § 165.

¶3It is urged that the evidence of unsatisfied judgments against Moore when he paid for the land, and directed it to be conveyed to his sister, was irrelevant to the issue made by the pleadings and should not be considered here. It is a part of the case as made by the record before us, and must have been so considered in the court below. It was received without objection, so far as the record shows.

¶4Had objection been made, an amendment of the answer to meet the objection would have been proper.

¶5Considering all the evidence in the ease, we think it clear that no trust resulted to L. B. Moore by reason of his payment of the purchase money of the lot, and

¶6We reverse the decree, but will not make a decree here; and remand the cause to the court below, where such further proceedings may be had as are proper in the opinion of the chancellor.

/1/missdec/50 · .json · Public domain