Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Morris 309

Bernard v. Parvin

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided January 15, 1844

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1844-01-15

This was an action of assumpsit brought by the plaintiffs against the defendant in error, upon a note of which the following is a copy : “ $317,81. “ Bloomington, September 1, 1842. “ One day after date, for value received, I promise to pay John A. Parvin, or order, three hundred and seventeen dollars and eighty-one cents, with interest at the rate of ten per cent per annum. “ WM.

Decided 1844-01-15

¶1Pee Curiam:

Mason, Chief Justice.

¶2The commencement of the declaration in this case reads as follows:

“ Joab Bernard & Overton Bernard, merchants, trading under the name and style of J. &. O. Bernard, complain &c.”

¶3The suit is brought against the defendant as endorser of a promissory note, which endorsement is in the words following :

“ November the 21st, 1842, I transfer the within note to J. & O. Bernard, with full recourse upon me.
(Signed) “ JOHN A. PARVIN.”

¶4On the trial below, the court charged the jury, that it was incumbent upon the plaintiffs to prove, that the firm of J. & O. Bernard, is composed of Joab Bernard & Overton Bernard. This is assigned for error, and raises the only question presented by the case.

¶5We think the court erred in giving the instruction. The statute declares that in all suits, brought upon any instrument of writing, made payable to partners trading together under their partnership name and style, it shall only be necessary to prove the partnership name and style, without proving the names of the individuals who compose the same. No direction is given as lo the shape of the commencement of the declaration, and although it would probably be as well to sue in the partnership name merely, still, as the statute makes no exceptions to the sweeping rule it has prescribed, we do not feel justified in making any.

¶6The judgment below, will therefore be set aside and a new trial ordered.

/1/morris/309 · .json · Public domain