Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Morris 93

Koons v. Dyer

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided July 15, 1841

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1841-07-15

Action, assumpsit. The plaintiff claimed by his declaration $146, but failing to prove one of the items, amounting to $100, defendant moved for a non-suit, on the ground that the amount to be recovered being less that $50, the Disrtict Court had no jurisdiction of the matter. This motion being sustained by the court, the plaintiff excepted and brought the cuase up by writ of error.

Decided 1841-07-15

¶1By the Court,

Mason, Chief Justice.

¶2We think the District Court erred in granting the nonsuit. Although justices of the peace have jurisdiction of suits for less that fifty dollars, we know of no law which deprives the District Courts of the jurisdiction of that class of cases. However desirable some restriction of this kind might be, the courts cannot fix one. The District Court is a court of general jurisdiction. To remove any class of cases out of such jurisdiction requires legislative action. Something more too, than merely conferring jurisdiction upon another court. As the law now stands the District Court has concurrent jurisdiction with justices of the peace, for all sums of fifty dollars and under and exclusive jurisdiction for all sums over that amount. The nonsuit granted in this case, will therefore be set aside and a writ of procedendo awarded to the District Court.

/1/morris/93 · .json · Public domain