Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 N.H. 251

Fowler v. Watkins

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided October 15, 1818

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1818-10-15

THIS was an action of trespass. The declaration contained two counts. 1. For assaulting and imprisoning the plaintiff four hours, on the 16th August, 1817. 2. For an assault, and imprisoning the plaintiff two hours, and until he paid two dollars, on the 20th August, 1817. The defendant pleaded, l. Not guilty, to the whole declaration. 2.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1879

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1818-10-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Richakjdson, C. J.

¶2The plaintiff’s motion to set aside the verdict, and award a repleader, cannot prevail. The plea in bar to the first count is sufficient. The plaintiff complains in that count that he was imprisoned four hours. The defendant alleges that he detained him in custody during that time, under a legal warrant. This is a sufficient answer. The warrant was in the nature of an execution : at all events, it was not returnable process — of course the defendant could not allege a return of it. See the precedents 2 C kitty's PI. 537, Sfc.

¶3Nor can the plaintiff’s motion for a new trial prevail. The replication to the plea in bar of the second count put in issue all the material facts alleged in that plea, and no other, and upon proving those facts the defendant was entitled to a verdict upon the issue. If other facts existed, which would have shewn the arrest to have been illegal, they should have been specially replied to the plea, but were certainly not admissible in evidence upon that issue. This point was decided in the case of Sayer vs. The Earl of Rockford, 1 Black. Rep. 1165. To an action of trespass the earl pleaded in justification a warrant against Sayer, and a commitment for treasonable practices. Sayer replied de injuria sua pro-pria absque tali causa', and under this issue attempted to give in evidence a tender and refusal of bail; but this evidence was rejected, on the ground that it ought to have been specially replied. — King and wife vs. Phippard, Carthew, 280. — 1 Chitty's Pl. 563, 599.

¶4Judgment for the defendant.

/1/nh/251 · .json · Public domain