Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Pa. Super. 125

Moore v. Grow

Superior Court of Pennsylvania

Decided January 20, 1896

Superior Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1896-01-20

<p>Appeal No. 20, Nov. T., 1895, by defendant, from order of C. P. Montgomery Co., discharging rule to open judgment.</p> <p>Exception to order discharging rule to open judgment.</p> <p>Judgment was entered in favor of the plaintiff, Samuel M. Moore, and against the defendant, Jacob Grow, for the sum of $24.00 on a single bill dated April 29, 1895. 'On July 6,1895, a rule was granted to show cause why judgment should not be opened and defendant let in to a defense. On September 15, 1895, the rule was discharged and an opinion filed by Swartz, P. J., which found the facts inter alia as follows:</p> <p>The plaintiff, Samuel M. Moore, a real estate broker, was employed to sell the farm of John H. Davidson. Through the agency of Moore the farm was sold to the defendant Jacob Grow at a valuation of $4,000. Under the contract of sale Davidson agreed to take in part payment of the purchase money the house and lot of Grow at a valuation of $1,200. After the sale or exchange was fully consummated Davidson paid to Moore a commission of two per centum on the $4,000 and Grow gave to Moore a judgment note for $24.00. Moore alleges that the note was given to secure the payment of commission due him by Grow.</p> <p>The note was entered of record and the defendant asks us to open the judgment, first because there was no consideration for the note, and secondly because the plaintiff was the agent of Davidson in the contract of sale, and therefore can have no valid claim for commissions against Grow.</p> <p>The allegations of the defendant that he never employed the plaintiff and never agreed to pay him commissions are contradicted by the note itself, by two witnesses who were present when the judgment note was executed and by the positive testimony of the plaintiff that on two occasions, before the sale was consummated, Grow agreed to pay commissions to plaintiff.</p> <p>Errors assigned were (1-3) refusing to open the judgment and discharging the rule.</p>

Affirmed · Decided 1896-01-20

¶1Opinion by

Orlady, J.,

¶2The plaintiff, a real estate broker, negotiated a sale of a farm, owned by John H. Davidson, to the defendant, at a price of $4,000. In part payment of his purchase, Davidson took title to-a house and lot owned by the defendant Grow, at a valuation of $1,200. As commission for his services rendered as broker, the plaintiff received two per centum on the $4,000 from Davidson, and a judgment note for $24.00 from the defendant. A judgment was entered in the court below on this note, which the defendant seeks to avoid for two reasons: First, because there was no consideration to support it; second, because the plaintiff was the agent of Davidson in the transaction, and can have no valid claim for commissions against him.

¶3Upon hearing of a rule to show cause why the judgment should not be opened and he let into a defense, testimony was taken, and after argument the court below discharged the rule. From this order and decree this appeal is taken, with three assignments of error.

¶4On examination of the evidence it is found that the testimony of the defendant stands unsupported by a single witness, nor is there any corroboration of his contention to be fairly drawn from it. Upon his own showing, the giving of the note was his deliberate act, after he had full knowledge of the facts, and in payment of that which he then regarded as a valid claim against him. He is contradicted by the note itself, and by the *129positive testimony of two witnesses who were present when the note was signed. He testifies in support of the rule', “ I took his (Davidson’s) property at $4,000, and he took mine at $1,200. We drew up articles of agreement, Mr. Moore did, and we both signed it. Mr. Davidson paid Mr. Jenkins and so did I. Mr. Moore then stepped up and said, ‘Now pay me.’ I looked at him. I said, ‘ I aint got the money to do it just now,’ and then he got a judgment note and drew it up. Mr. Moore then handed me a judgment note, and he said sign it, and I did so,” and all this in the office of the attorney who passed upon the title, and also in presence of three persons in addition to the plaintiff. There was no mistake in the execution of the note. Using the house and lot of Grow in part payment of the farm of Davidson was as well understood as any other fact. The consideration of the note was known by all who testified in relation to the matter to be defendant’s debt for broker’s commission. The broker was in the employ of both, a fact well known by each. The integrity of the judgment, or the good faith of the transaction, has not been successfully attacked, and the decree of- the court was well supported by the law and facts.

¶5The judgment is affirmed.

/1/pasuper/125 · .json · Public domain