Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Tenn. 211

State v. Evans

Tennessee Superior Court for Law and Equity · decided 1806-09-06

Indictment for horse stealing a capital offence.* On monday in the second week of the term, the defendant was brought out, and charged; upon being asked if he had counsel, he answered that he had not; that he was not able to employ any; that he had been speaking to Mr. M'Campbell, who had not as yet undertaken for him; upon which the prisoner had a short conversation with Mr. M'Campbell, who informed the court, that he had been retained by the prisoner as his counsel and…

Relies on Wheelwright v. Depeyster · Oni v. Meek

Decided 1806-09-06

¶1The best evidence in such cases is furnished by facts not opinions; if facts exist, such as paying taxes, going to muster, or exercising the rights of sovereignty by either State; if no such proof on account of the newness of the settlement can be had, common opinion may be resorted to: not the opinion of the witnesses. The common opinion in this case was, that the locus in quo was within this State; if without the limits of this State we clearly should not have jurisdiction.1 Kaims' Pr. Eq. 547, 548; Williams for defendant cited2 Haw. 94, § 21; Morg. Essays, 424. The attorney-general in reply, 2 M'N. 577, 579.

¶2Verdict, guilty. Judgment of death; hut the defendant was afterwardspardoned.

¶31 See Tay. 65; 1 Hay. 101; 2 Hay. 79; 1 Johns. 477, 479.

/1/tenn/211 · .json · Public domain