Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Thompson 48

Spalding v. Kincaid

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1850

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1850-09-15

This cause was tried in tbe Circuit Court of Claiborne County in 1845; and from tbe judgment then and there rendered, an appeal was prayed and granted to tbe Supreme Court. Five years elapsed, during which time no transcript of the record was forwarded to .the Supreme Court, nor did the appellant take any steps toward prosecuting his appeal.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently August 1938

3 state decisions

Relies on Weakly's Lessee v. Wilson and Simmons · Suggs v. Suggs · Norwood v. Humphreys

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1850-09-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McKInney, J.:

¶1The act of 1829, chapter 103, section 2, forbids the Court to dismiss any cause without examining it upon its merits. The prayer in this case is for simple appeal. No such appeal lies at law; and it must be construed to ■ mean an appeal in error. That, like a writ of error, does not vacate the judgment below, but operates as a supersedeas. We see no reason why the appellee cannot at any time file the record, and we can apply no statute of limitations to him. The case *49being before us, we are bound to look into its merits. There is no error in- the record. [1]

¶2Judgment affirmed.

¶3(1) Appellee may produce transcript in Supreme Court and move for an affirmance of judgment, when. Freeman v. Henderson, 5 Cold. 647 ; Furber v. Carter, 2 Sneed 1. And the appellant cannot be heard to. object on account of lapse of time, since appeal. Ib. As to affirmance in similar cases in appeal to Circuit Court, see Code 3143, 3150, 3151. See also Bustard v. Cheatham, 1 Tenn. 370; Norwood v. Humphreys, 2 Tenn. 188; Stuart v. Pasmore, 5 Hayw. 30; Nichols v. Colvill, 1 Tenn. 81; Gregory v. Burnett, 1 Humph. 60; McDonald v. Smith, 7 Yerg.304; Duncan v. McGee, 7 Yerg. 103; Suggs v. Suggs, 1 Tenn. 2.

/1/thompson/48 · .json · Public domain