Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Wright 37

Brown v. Kincaid

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided April 15, 1832

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 1832-04-15

Slander. The declaration alleged, that a suit had been pending between Kincaid, the plaintiff, and Brown, the defendant, before a justice, which was submitted to the arbitrament of J. K. and J. E. That on the trial of said cause, before the arbitrators, the plaintiff was sworn and examined as a witness, as to his book account, of less than eighteen months’ standing, which he claimed to offset, and that the defendant, in speaking of the trial, the plaintiff, and his evidence,…

Decided 1832-04-15

BY THE COURT.

¶1The motion is overruled; Parties may submit to the arbitrament of any number of men. The statutory arbi*39tration *does not take away the common law right. If it be [38 necessary to prove that the arbitrators were sworn, that fact may be proven by parol. The omission to return an award to the parties, if true, is no objection here, more than it would be upon a charge of perjury, committed by a witness before a court or jury, to urge that the court or jury could not agree upon a verdict and judgment. Verdict for the plaintiff, for twenty-seven dollars and fifty cents.

Srazee moved in arrest of judgment,

¶2because there was no colloquium set forth in the declaration.

¶3BY THE COURT. It is true, as claimed by the defendant, that where words are not actionable in themselves, but become so by reason of their relation to some other thing, the plaintiff must set forth, as inducement, the matter relied upon in the declaration, and show the relation which the words complained of have to such matter. This declaration does both. It sets forth the case, the trial, the oath, the testimony given by plaintiff, and that the words complained of, were spoken of the plaintiff, the trial, and the evidence. The motion is overruled.

¶4Judgment on the verdict.

¶5[Common law mode of arbitration is in force in Ohio; State v. Jackson, 36 O. S. 281, 284.]

/1/wright/37 · .json · Public domain