Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Ala. 346

Palmer v. Severance

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 15, 1846

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1846-06-15

Writ of Error to the Circuit Court of Russell. Assumpsit, by Ann Palmer, for the use of Jesse A. Palmer, against Severance & Stewart, as the joint makers of a promissory note. At the trial, it was proved the note was given for the loan of money at usurious interest, and that the principal 'sum had been paid previous to the commencement of the suit.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently June 1868

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1846-06-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

GOLDTHWAITE, J.

¶1The construction hitherto given to the statute, which makes joint obligations, &c., joint and several, [Digest, 323, § 61,] has been, that it does not warrant the discontinuance of the suit, when commenced against several, except as to those who are not served with process; [Keebles v. Ford, 5 Ala. Rep. 183; Saddler v. Houston, 5 S. & P. 20§; Adkins v. Allen, 1 Stewart, 130,] and that if one is discharged by verdict, T5n a defence which does not arise subsequent to the contract, or is persenal to the defendant insisting upon it, it will prevent, or be sufficient cause to arrest the judgment against the others. [Ivy v. Gamble, 7 Porter, 545; Turner v. Lazarus, 6 Ala. Rep. 875.] But although the arrest of the judgment is the consequence when one is thus discharged, it does not follow that when one only succeeds in making good the common defence, or that is obviated as to the other, that a general verdict shall be returned for both defendants. The effect of a general verdict would be to bar the plaintiff afterwards of his several action against the defendant really liable to him, which is entirely different from the consequences which follow an arrest of judgment. We think the charge, in this view, was erroneous, and the court should have permitted a verdict according to the proof, leaving it afterwards to the parties to move for judgment, or to annul it as they should be advised.

¶2Judgment of non-suit reversed, and cause remanded.

/10/ala/346 · .json · Public domain