Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Ala. 958

Boswell v. Tunnell

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided January 15, 1847

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1847-01-15

Writ of Error to the County Court of Fayette. AotioN of assumpsit by Tunnell and wife against Boswell. The defendant pleaded in abatement, that before the writ in this cause was issued, the plaintiffs impleaded him for the same identical causes of action before a justice’s court, and obtained judgment thereon against him, upon which he appealed the said cause to the county court, where it was pending against him, at the return term of said writ.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1902

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1847-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

GOLDTHWAITE, J.

¶1We think this plea well pleaded. It avers the identity of the parties — of the cause of action— that judgment was given against the defendant — and that this judgment was appealed to the county court, where it was pending at the return of the writ. It would be a strained .conclusion, that the a ppeal was not pending, when the assertion is, the judgment .was obtained the 2d of June, and *959only five clays are allowed to take the appeal. The writ issued on the 11th and consequently must have been after the appeal was taken. But independent of this construction of the plea, as it stands, there Avould be no reason why the defendant should not have pleaded a former recovery, if the facts are as the plaintiffs suppose them.

¶2The plea being well pleaded, there was error in sustaining the demurrer.

¶3Judgment reversed and cause remanded.

/10/ala/958 · .json · Public domain