Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Johns. 363

Cary v. Campbell

New York Supreme Court

Decided August 15, 1813

New York Supreme Court · decided 1813-08-15

IN ERROR, on certiorari, from a justice’s court. Cary sued Campbell and Coolc, before the justice, on a promissory note. The defendants pleaded non assumpsit and a set-off. There was a trial by jury. The justice certified that the note was dev u v o livcred to him by the plaintiff when the issue was joined; but that on search he could not find it, and that he permitted the plaintiff io give parol proof of the note, though the defendants objected to it.

Decided 1813-08-15

Per Curiam.

¶1The justice erred in admitting parol proof of the note, as a lost note, when there was no proof of its being lost. What the justice might have said as to the loss, was no legal evidence to the jury. It was requisite that proof on oath should have been given of the loss of the note, before the secondary evidence could be let in. Without examining the other points suggested, the evidence offered by the plaintiff was not sufficient to entitle him to recover, and the verdict was correct.

¶2Judgment affirmed-

/10/johns/363 · .json · Public domain