Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Johns. 418

Saxton v. Johnson

New York Supreme Court

Decided October 15, 1813

New York Supreme Court · decided 1813-10-15

THIS was an action of assumpsit. The declaration contained *lv0 counts; the first on a promissory note in the usual form; and °thei' for money paid, money lent, and money had and received to the use of the plaintiffs.

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently July 1855

3 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1813-10-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1The words for value received, in the first count in the declaration, were used and intended for a description of the note declared on; and not as an averment inserted by the pleader. The precedents of declarations on promissory notes are all in that way; and no counsel on the part of thé defendant would have supposed that these words were inserted as an averment of value ; and if he had demurred in consequence of a defective averment of the consideration, the court, no doubt, would *426have considered the words as part of the note. There was, thei,, a variance between the instrument declared on, and the one given in evidence, and the plaintitTh, at the trial, failed in the requisite evidence in support of their first count.

¶2The next question is, whether the note was admissible in evidence under the money count.

¶3If the note had contained, on the face of it, an admission of a consideration, or value received, it might, perhaps, have been admitted, but it had none; and as it was not a note within the statute, but a special contract, it required a consideration to be stated or averred. To give the note in evidence, without any consideration averred, or any consideration appearing on the face of it, would be taking the defendant by surprise, without giving him due . opportunity to contest the consideration, which might have been Set up at the trial.

¶4The motion to set aside the nonsuit' is denied.

¶5Motion denied.

/10/johns/418 · .json · Public domain