Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Mass. 281

Leonard & Leonard

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 15, 1813

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1813-09-15

<p>Of the seisin necessary to maintain a writ of right</p> <p>[Where lands were devised to four brothers, one of them a minor, and the three of age agreed to divide the whole lands between them, and one of them, the ancestor of defendant, having received from the others a certain sum of money, agreed to purchase other lands for the minor, and satisfy him for his portion, according to the judgment of indifferent men, and save the executors harmless from all claim of the minor when of age ; and the defendant’s ancestor took possession of the d manded premises devised as aforesaid, and he and his heirs occupied them for more than sixty years without any claim ever having been made by the minor before or after coming of age, or by his heirs, till the bringing of the suit after this lapse of time; and the minor, when of age, having received certain lands and money in part compensation for his portion, and a conveyance of other lands having been awarded to him for the residue, which had never been conveyed; — held, that his heirs, the demandants, were barred by the possession of defendant and his ancestor for more than sixty years. — Ed.]</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently September 1866

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1813-09-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Curia.

¶1We think the verdict in this case must be confirmed; and that the opinion given at the trial, and by which the jury were directed, was undoubtedly correct.

¶2The tenant shows a seisin in himself, and his ancestor, Daniel Leonard, of more than sixty years before this action was commenced ; that is, from 1748, the date of his agreement for a compensation to Russell; which serves at least the purpose of proving an ouster of Russell from the demanded premises, or a sole and exclusive seisin claimed on the part of Daniel. He had then the possession and seisin, declaring his intention to exclude Russell therefrom; and in this exclusion Russell, after he came of age, acquiesced, and received, in part at least, the compensation provided for him by the agreement among his brethren, the co-devisees named in the will of their father.

¶3Admitting the presumption of law to be, as the counsel for the demandants contended, upon the fact of a devise to the [ * 284 ] four brothers, and a possession by one of them, if* nothing more was proved, that it must be construed the seisin of the co-devisees; yet the agreement of the three brothers then of age, and the entry of Daniel, pursuant to that agreement, and in *283execution of their design to exclude Russell, and to refer him to a provision to be made for him by Daniel, repels all presumption of a continued seisin in Russell.

¶4There is, therefore, the fullest evidence that can be required in any case, to prove a disseisin of Russell; and there is no evidence, on the part of the demandants, to prove that Russell, by any act or entry of his, had any seisin, in law or in fact, within sixty years before the action brought, as in their writ is alleged. This allega tion is essential to be proved in support of their right of action; and, failing in this, the tenant was entitled to a verdict, (a)

¶5 Judgment on the verdict.

¶6 [Vide Cummings vs. Wyman, post, 464. — Brown & Al. vs. Wood & Ux. 17 Mass. Rep. 68. — Shumway vs Holbrook, 1 Pick. 114. — Barnard vs. Pope, 14 Mass. Rep. 434. — Higbee vs. Rice, 5 Mass. Rep. 344.— Chapman vs. Gray, 15 Mass. Rep 439 - Ed.]

/10/mass/281 · .json · Public domain