Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Nev. 443

State v. Derst

Nevada Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1876

Nevada Supreme Court · decided 1876-01-15

The facts are stated in the opinion. The indictment is fatally defective. It does not in direct language charge the commission of any offense whatever. The most favorable construction that can be given it is that it charges the larceny of a jewelry-box; but nowhere is there any allegation that the box was of any value except in connection with other articles, which we respectfully submit the defendant is not charged with stealing.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently June 1960

2 state decisions

Relies on State v. O'Flaherty · People v. Logan

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1876-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1By tke Court,

Be at tv, J.:

¶2The defendant was convicted of grand larceny upon an indictment Avkick charged him with stealing “one jewelry-box, containing two gold watches and chains, of the value of one hundred and fifty dollars; also, a large lot of jewelry, consisting of finger-rings, ear-rings, pins and chains, of the value of three hundred dollars; all of said property, viz., the jewelry-box and its contents, was of the value of four hundred and fifty dollars, of the goods and chattels of one J. Jacoby,” etc.

¶3On the trial, he objected to evidence of the value of the watches and chains upon the grounds that the indictment did not state facts sufficient to constitute an offense, and that it did not charge a larceny of the watches and chains. His objection was overruled; he excepted to tho ruling and assigns it as error.

¶4The argument in support of the assignment is that a charge of stealing a box containing watches is not a charge of stealing the watches, except by way of inference, which is not sufficient. This position is no doubt correct, but the objection goes to the form and not to the substance of the allegation, and is waived by a failure to demur.

¶5In Logan’s ease (1 Nev. 110), which is relied on by appellant, it will be observed there was a demurrer to the indictment. • In a later case — that of O’Flaherty (7 Nev. 157-8) —it was held, that whore no objection is made to the indictment before judgment, it is sufficient if the requisite facts can be implied from the allegations on the record by *445fair and reasonable intendment. Can it be implied, then, by fair and reasonable intendment from the allegations of this indictment that the defendant is charged with stealing the watches and chains ? We think it is necessarily implied. A man cannot steal a box containing a watch which is the property of the owner of the box without stealing the watch.

¶6The cases cited from Massachusetts are not in point, for two reasons. In the first place, the Massachusetts bill of rights entitles a defendant to have his offense “fully and plainly, substantially and formally described to him,” while our Constitution does not require formality of statement, and the statute expressly dispenses with it. In the second place, both of the cases relied on (9 Kick. 142, and 3 Pick. 281) are decided upon the ground that the necessary facts cannot be implied from the allegations of the indictments. In one it is held, that having a license to keep an inn does not imply that the holder keeps an inn. In the other, an allegation that a man has not constructed a draw to his bridge, is held not to imply that he has any bridge; in both of w’hich conclusions we should readily agree.

¶7We think there was no error in the ruling of the court, and the judgment is affirmed.

/10/nev/443 · .json · Public domain