Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Rob. 178

Laizer v. Generes

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided March 15, 1845

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1845-03-15

This was an action by the purchaser against the vendor of certain lots in the city of Lafayette, to recover from the latter, on the ground of eviction, a part of the price, which had been paid, the value of the improvements put upon the property, &c. There was a judgment in favor of the plaintiff for the part of the price of the property paid by him. As to the rest of the claim, there was a judgment for the defendant.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently May 1934

3 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1845-03-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Martin, J.

¶1The plaintiff, evicted from several lots which he had purchased from the defendant, institutes this suit to recover the amount of a note for $750, by him paid, the value of his improvements, and the costs for advertising a monition.

¶2lie had judgment for the first item. There was judgment *179against him on the second, the court being of opinion that he had been compensated therefor by the rents which he had received during his possession of the premises. Likewise, on the third, the court observing that the deed from the defendant to him showed that the latter had bound himself to pay the costs of the monition. The defendant appealed.

¶3The claim was resisted on the ground' that the amount of the note was compensated by rents received by the plaintiff before the eviction; that the improvements, for which compensation is claimed, were improperly made, after the plaintiff had notice of Connolly’s opposition on the monition, under which the sale by the sheriff and the present defendant was set aside.

¶4The plaintiff and appellee prays for the amendment of the judgment in his favor, by allowing him the value of the improvements, and the expense of advertising the monition.

¶5The counsel for the plaintiff and appellee has relied on the Civil Code, art. 2485, which provides that “ the seller is bound to reimburse, or cause to be reimbursed to the buyer, all useful improvementsand has urged, that in a sale the property passes forever to the buyer; and that, on his eviction, his warrantor has no right to compensate the improvements with the rents.

¶6It appears to us that judgment was properly given in favor of the plaintiff for the amount of the note, which was part of the price of the property sold. Judgment was correctly given in favor of the defendant on the rest of' the case. He was a bona fide possessor, and as such had a claim for the reimbursement of all he expended in useful improvements; and he made the fruits his own until the inception'of the suit. Civil Code, art. 495. It is otherwise with regard to the improvements. Until they are reimbursed to him he has a right to retain the property. Civil Code, 3416.

¶7In the present case, however, the plaintiff ought to have demanded the value of his improvements from the party who recovered the premises, and ought not to have abandoned them until he was sued, or was paid for them. He was too hasty in-quitting the premises before.

¶8Judgment was also correctly given for the defendant, for the *180costs of the advertisements, the plaintiff having engaged to pay the costs of the monition.

¶9The plaintiff may still claim the value of his useful improvements from the party who has recovered the premises, and taken possession, of them.

¶10Judgmemt affirmed.

/10/rob/178 · .json · Public domain