Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 S.C. 311

Hinson v. Catoe

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided November 22, 1878

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1878-11-22

Bepoee MACKEY, J., at Lancaster, October Term, 1875. Held: when it was heard upon an affidavit by the plaintiff, dated 17th August, 1877, which stated: “ That in the trial of the above case for the recovery of said note the defendant was allowed credits as discounts — one for ten dollars and another for seventy-five dollars — for which said amounts the plaintiff had given the defendant…

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently April 1918

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1878-11-22

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Haskell, A. J.

¶2The order appealed from cannot come under the provisions of the Act of 1869, (Rev. Stat., p. 497,) for no judgment has been entered. Section 289 of the Code, Revised Statutes, p. 636, requires that a motion for a new trial, except where it is based upon a case and “ exceptions,” shall “ be heard and decided at the same term.” By the context it' is made apparent that the “same term” means the term at which the trial was had.

¶3The motion in this instance was made at the same term on the minutes, but was heard and decided after the lapse of nearly two years, during which time, of course, several terms had occurred. The affidavit to support the motion bears date nearly two years after the trial and is of the date of the term at which the motion was heard and decided. To hear and decide at such term a motion made merely upon the minutes made by the Judge at the trial was clearly wrong. Moreover, the affidavit shows conclusively that the evidence therein set up was not “ newly-discovered,” as stated in the *314Judge’s order, but had been in the knowledge of the respondent at the time of the trial, and was then offered, but objection was made that the mode of proof by which he sought to introduce the evidence was secondary. The objection was sustained by the Court, and no appeal was taken. It is useless for the respondent to say that the papers which constituted the best evidence had been lost and now are found. On proof of the loss in the manner prescribed by the rules of evidence the secondary proof would have been admissible. The respondent admits that at the time of the trial he was acquainted with the facts which he sets up now as ground for new trial, but that he had failed in his efforts to prove them, by a mistaken view, on his part, of the law of evidence. That is no ground for a new trial.

¶4The order granting a new trial is reversed.

¶5Motion granted.

Willard, C. J., and Molver, A. J., concurred.
/10/sc/311 · .json · Public domain