Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

100 Mass. 146

Commonwealth v. Durfee

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 15, 1868

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1868-10-15

<p>Indictment for adultery with Esther Haskins., Trial in the superior court, before Brigham, J., who allowed a bill of exceptions of which the following are the material parts:</p> <p>Samuel B. Bumpas, a witness for the Commonwealth, after testifying tó seeing the performance of the criminal act at a particular place on his farm, was allowed, against the defendant’s objection, to testify further as follows : “ I have seen the parties walking and sitting together many times at various places on my farm when no other person was with them. I have seen them sitting together under the trees. I have seen them go in the direction of this place. I should think they were not relations.” There was no statement in the bill of exceptions of the time to which the testimony quoted had relation; whether before or after the criminal act testified to, or both before and after it.</p> <p>“ The jury retired at about eight o’clock on the evening of the day of the trial, and by direction of the presiding judge were allowed to disperse, by the officer having them in charge, upon the following morning at about one o’clock, when they had given notice to said officer that they had agreed upon and sealed up their verdict. At nine o’clock on the same morning they came into court and rendered an oral verdict of guilty. The contents of any paper sealed by them were not made known to the defendant or his counsel; and no sealed verdict was produced or opened. Neither the defendant nor his counsel had notice of the direction of the judge that the jury should be allowed to disperse upon agreeing and sealing up their verdict, or consented to such dispersion; and before they rendered their verdict the defendant’s counsel objected to the taking and recording of it, on the ground and only on the ground that they had separated without his consent and contrary to law.”</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1868-10-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently February 1965

1 federal appellate · 9 state decisions

3018681870188018901900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Chapman, C. J.

¶11. Evidence of an act of adultery may be corroborated by evidence of prior acts of familiarity between the parties. Commonwealth v. Merriam, 14 Pick. 518. The defendant’s exceptions do not show that the acts of familiarity proved in this case were subsequent to the alleged act of adultery.

¶22. But the verdict was not regularly rendered. Even in civil cases it is required that, if the jury separate after being sent out, the fact that they agreed before they separated shall be evidenced by a verdict sealed up and brought into court. Less strictness ought not to be tolerated in a criminal case than is is required in a civil case. In this case, the jury separated, and when they came into court the next morning they did not present a sealed verdict, but rendered an oral verdict just as they would have done if they had not separated. It is true that the written verdict which is returned in a civil case is placed on file as the verdict of the jury, while in a criminal case a general verdict is oral. But the permission which is given to the jury to separate in a criminal case is always on condition that before their separation they shall reduce their verdict to writing, signed by their foreman and sealed up. Such appears to have been the direction in this case. We know of no authority or practice allowing them to separate without doing this, except when they are discharged because they cannot agree; or for receiving their verdict after such separation, without having the sealed verdict opened and read in court" nor do we see any reason for relaxing the rule. Exceptions sustained.

/100/mass/146 · .json · Public domain