Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

100 N.C. 509

6 S.E 91

State v. . Keene

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided February 5, 1888

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1888-02-05

This is an indictment for murder, tried before Connor, J., at February Term, 1888, of Rowan Superior Court. Only two questions are presented for our consideration, and they are clearly presented in the ease on -appeal, as follows: “ The prisoner’s counsel, after the jury was empaneled, and before the introduction of any testimony, informed the Court that the prisoner desired to admit that he killed the deceased with a deadly weapon, averring that the killing was accidental.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently January 1978

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1888-02-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Davis, J.

¶1 (After stating the facts). 1.‘The first exception can not be maintained.

¶2 The decision of the Court below upon the question as to who should have the reply and the conclusion of the argument was “ final and not reviewable ” by this Court. By Rule 6, to be found on page 852 of 92 N. C., Rep., this is settled. Brooks v. Brooks, 90 N. C., 142; Cheek v. Watson, 90 N. C., 302; Austin v. Secrest, 91 N. C., 214.

¶3 “ It is only when no evidence is introduced by the defendant” that the right of reply and conclusion belongs, of right, to his counsel, by Rule 3, to be found on page 851 of the same volume.

¶4 2. The second exception is also untenable. It is not denied, that Dr. Summerell' is an expert, and this case is easily distinguishable from that of the State v. Bowman, 78 N. C., 509. In fact, the question put to Dr. Summerell was in strict compliance with the mode laid down for the examination of experts in State v. Bowman, and the reasoning in that case, and the authorities cited therein, fully sustain the ruling of the Court below. See also Ray v. Ray, 98 N. C., 566; State v. Cole, 94 N. C., 959.

¶5 There is no error.

¶6 Affirmed.

/100/nc/509 · .json · Public domain