Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

101 Ga. 290

Stone v. Nix

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided May 21, 1897

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1897-05-21

Equitable petition. Before Judge Butt. Muscogee superior court. May term, 1896. A demurrer to the petition of Mrs. Sallie Stone against William A. Nix was sustained, and the plaintiff excepted. She alleged that in March, 1880, she purchased of him 172 acres of land described, for the agreed price of $500, which she paid to him, and he executed to her his deed conveying the land to her. She rented the land to him, and he has possession thereof as her tenant.

Decided 1897-05-21

Lumpkin, P. J.

¶1Amendments to petitions are very frequently offered which, upon objection, should not be allowed; but when an amendment to a petition has, without objection, been duly allowed by an order of the court, it must, of course, be treated as a part of the petition.

¶2The plaintiff in the present case filed a petition to foreclose, as an equitable mortgage, an instrument in the form of an absolute deed. An amendment to the petition, which was duly allowed, alleged, in substance, that in another case between the same parties this identical instrument had been finally adjudicated to be, not an absolute deed, but a mortgage. The court, on demurrer, erroneously dismissed the plaintiff’s proceeding. Taking as true the allegations of the petition as .amended, the paper sought to be foreclosed should have been ■dealt with as an equitable mortgage, because the adjudication above mentioned, whether in the first instance rightly made or not, was certainly binding and conclusive upon the defendant, and its effect, as between these parties, was to give the instrument that character, force and effect.

¶3Judgment reversed.

All the Justices cuncurring.
/101/ga/290 · .json · Public domain