Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

101 Ga. 665

Walker v. Pope

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided July 8, 1897

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1897-07-08

<p>1. Where one, assuming to act as trustee for an adult laboring under no disability, undertook to sell and convey in fee simple land in which the latter had a life-estate with remainder in fee to his children, and thereafter filed with the ordinary an application averring that his appointment and acts as trustee (specially mentioning the sale above referred to ) were unauthorized because the supposed cestui que trust was a person for whom no trust could be lawfully created, and praying for leave to make a final settlement with such person, and upon so doing,to be discharged from the trust; and where the children of this person, in a writing attached to the application, expressly ratified the applicant’s acts as trustee and consented to the granting of the order as prayed for, and after the same had been granted the so-called trustee did settle with the so-called cestui que trust and pay over to him certain cash, Held: (a) That as to one who upon the faith of this writing and the proceeding before the ordinary, of which it constituted a part, bona fide and for value purchased the land from the alleged trustee’s vendee, or his legal representative, the children who were adults when they signed this paper are estopped from questioning the validity of the sale made by the alleged trustee. (6) Under the facts recited, it would be a question for a jury whether or not the above would be applicable to a child who, though a minor when he signed such paper, allowed it to remain of record in the court of ordinary without challenge or attack until after the title had passed from the estate of such vendee to an innocent purchaser who bought upon the faith of a representation made by the seller that all of these children had in court signed the paper ratifying the original sale, this purchase occurring about two years after the signing of the paper and the proceeding before the ordinary, the particular child now referred to having been of age during the latter half of this period, and there being nothing in the record of that proceeding showing his minority. The determination of this question would depend on whether or not such child had, under all the circumstances, allowed an unreasonable time to elapse without disaffirming his action in signing the paper in question, (c) That a child who signed this paper while a minor of tender years, and who was still a minor when the purchaser last referred to acquired title, is, as to the latter’, not so estopped, either by reason of having signed the paper, or because of having delayed asserting his title until after the death of the life-tenant.</p> <p>2. It appearing that in a joint action for land brought by several persons one or more of them can not recover, there can be no recovery by any of the plaintiffs.</p> <p>3. There was no error in admitting evidence; and in view of the law by which this case upon its facts as they appeared at the trial is controlled, the charges complained of, even if not strictly correct and appropriate, were harmless to the losing parties. The verdict was right; but direction is given that neither it nor the judgment entered thereon shall be so construed as to prevent the two children last indicated from hereafter asserting whatever rights they, or either of them, may have, if any, to an undivided interest in the premises in dispute.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1897-07-08

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently January 1972

9 state decisions

50189719001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Fish, J.

¶1The principles of law governing this case are well settled and familiar, and will be readily gathered from the headnotes, read in connection with the reporter's statement of the facts.

¶2 Judgment affirmed, with direction.

All the Justices concurring.
/101/ga/665 · .json · Public domain