Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

103 F. 991

Converse v. Parmly

United States Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York · decided 1900-07-02

<p>Demurrer to Complaint in an Action at Law.</p>

1 counsel of record

Decided 1900-07-02

¶1Demurrer to Complaint in an Action at Law.

¶2Randolph Parmly and Arthur H. Masten, for demurrer, diaries A. Deshon, opposed.

¶3LACOMBE, Circuit Judge.

¶4The complaint apparently declares upon a primary agreement of defendant to respond for losses, and not a guaranty that Prescott & Brooks shall respond for them. Indeed, no indebtedness of Prescott & Brooks to plaintiff for such losses is alleged, nor is there sufficient in the complaint to warrant such a holding. When the proofs are in the case may present a different aspect, but on the pleadings alone the demurrer must be overruled. Leave to answer within 20 days.

/103/f1d/991 · .json · Public domain