Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

103 Wis. 269

State ex rel. Graff v. Everett

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided May 16, 1899

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1899-05-16

<p>Certiorari: Town boards: Service upon clerk: Return: Jurisdiction.</p> <p>1. A writ of certiorari to review the acts of a hoard or body, unless it is not a continuing body or has ceased to exist, must go to the board, and, when directed to the legal custodian of its records, does not confer jurisdiction either of the subject matter or of the persons composing the board.</p> <p>2. The return of a person, not competent to receive service of a writ of certiorari and make return, is a nullity.</p> <p>3. A town board is a permanent body, and when its acts are sought to be reviewed on certiorari the writ should be directed to and served on its members as such board.</p>

Relies on State ex rel. Flint v. Common Council of Fond du Lac · State ex rel. Ollinger v. Town of Manitowoc · State ex rel. Clancy v. McGovern

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1899-05-16

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently March 1966

6 state decisions

4018991900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Maeshall, J.

¶1It has been repeatedly held by this court that, except in particular cases of necessity, as where the board or body whose acts are sought to be reviewed is not a continuing body or has ceased to exist, a writ of certiora/ri cannot properly go to a mere ministerial officer because he is the legal custodian of the records showing the facts in regard to the action to be reviewed, but that the writ must go to the board, otherwise the court cannot obtain jurisdiction either of the subject matter or the persons composing such board; and that a return by a person who is not competent to receive service of the writ and make return thereto is a nullity. State ex rel. Tibbits v. Milwaukee, 86 Wis. 376; State ex rel. Ollinger v. Manitowoc, 92 Wis. 546; State ex rel. Clancy v. McGovern, 100 Wis. 666; State ex rel. Flint v. Common Council of Fond du Lac, 42 Wis. 287. That rule governs this case. The town board was a permanent body. The writ should have been directed to the members thereof as such board. The issuance of the writ and service of it upon the clerk, and his return thereto, gave the court no jurisdiction and therefore it was properly quashed. If the court had proceeded to dispose of the matter complained of on the merits, the judgment would have been a nullity. State ex rel. Ollinger v. Manitowoc, supra.

¶2By the Cowrt.— The order appealed from is affirmed.

/103/wis/269 · .json · Public domain