Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

104 Ala. 437

Spigener v. Rives

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided November 15, 1893

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1893-11-15

Tried before the Hon. N. D. Denson. The facts of the case are sufficiently stated in the opinion. The last four sections in the act involved in this suit are unconstitutional ; and all the various sections of the said act being so mutually connected with and dependent on each other, as that the provisions of the act itself can not be carried into effect without the four last sections, which are unconstitutional, the act itself is void. — Cooley’s Const.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently May 1923

2 state decisions

Relies on Davis v. State · Ex parte Cowert · Powell v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1893-11-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

COLEMAN, J.

¶1The appellant sued the appellee in *438trespass for taking up cattle which were trespassing upon his lands. The appellee justified under an. act approved February 18th, 1891, (Acts 1890-91, pp. 1144-1148, inclusive), entitled-“An act to prevent the running at large of stock in certain portions of Elmore county. ’ ’ The only question presented is as to the constitutionality of the act. That laws to prevent the running of stock at large within certain districts are within the constitutional power of the legislature can not be questioned. — McGraw v. The County Commissioners of Greene, 89 Ala. 407; Stanfill v. Court of County Revenue of Dallas County, 80 Ala. 287 ; Davis v. State, 68 Ala. 58. It is contended by appellant that sections 10-13, inclusive, are violative of constitutional provisions contained in sections two and five of Article XI. — Code, page 43. The writer of this opinion does not think it necessary to decide whether the sections of the act referred to are liable to the objections ui-ged against them or not. The sections of the act under which the defendant justified, in my opinion, are separable from those sections against which the objection is made. — Ex parte Cotoart, 92 Ala. 99; Powell v. The State, 69 Ala. 10 ; McCreary v. The State, 73 Ala. 480 ; 3 Brick. Dig. 127, § 18; Noble & Ware v. Mitchell, 100 Ala. 519. My associates are of opinion that the constitutional provision cited has no application to the statute, and that the whole act is free from constitutional objection. We all concur in the conclusion that the statute afforded a complete defense to the defendant.

¶2Affirmed.

/104/ala/437 · .json · Public domain