Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

104 N.C. 350

10 S.E 252

McNair v. . Pope

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided September 5, 1889

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1889-09-05

Receiver — Fin ancial Judgment — Agricultural Lien — Inter-vener — Disposition of Rents in hands of Receiver. This was an appeal from the rulings of his Honor, Philips, J., at RobesoN Superior Court, May Term, 1888. The object of this action was to enforce an alleged parol trust, and the issue's were decided adversely to the plaintiffs, and it was adjudged that the defendants were the owners and entitled to the possession of the land in controversy.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1940

1 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“that the lienees are entitled to be paid for any advances, etc.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Roughton v. . Duncan

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1889-09-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

*353 Shepherd, J.

¶1 — after stating the facts: His ITonor very properly allowed A. &W. McQueen, the agricultural lienees, to intervene and assert their alleged rights in the fund held by the receiver. It is true that there had been a final determination of the issues raised upon the pleadings, but no order had been made as to the rents which had been collected by the receiver, and so far as these were concerned, the cause was still open for further directions.

¶2 The order of reference to the Clerk, and the refusal of the Court to direct that the entire fund should be paid to the defendants, were correct. There was error, however, in withholding from the defendants the rents for the years 1887 and 1888. These should have been paid to the defendants, as the agricultural lienees can, in no aspect of the case, be entitled to any part of them, their lien only covering the . products of the year 1886.

¶3 It appears from the record, and is conceded here, that the plaintiffs were in possession of the land, claiming it as theirown, until the receiver entered. It is very clear that the lienees are entitled to be paid for any advances they may have made up to that time, and the amount of these will be, ascertained by the Clerk under the order of reference.

¶4 If there were any advances after the action of the receiver, the circumstances under which they were made should be reported, so that the Court can determine whether the lienees are entitled to be paid for the same

¶5 Modified and affirmed.

/104/nc/350 · .json · Public domain