Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

105 Mich. 398

Mower v. Verplanke

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided May 21, 1895

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1895-05-21

<p>Appeal — Point not raised below — Probate of foreign will — Sufficiency of petition.</p> <p>1, A point not raised upon the trial should not be considered on appeal.</p> <p>2. A petition for the probate of a foreign will, which sets forth ■that the petitioner is interested “as a subsequent purchaser of the estate of the deceased,” is sufficient, under How. Stat. § 5800, which provides that “when a copy of such will and, the probate thereof, duly authenticated, shall be produced by the executor, or other person interested in such will, to the probate court, such court shall appoint a time and-place ' of. hearing, and notice shall be given in the samé manner '.■.'■as in the case of an original will presented for probate.’": to give .the. probate court .jurisdiction, it not., being neces7 sary to set forth the proofs of petitioner’s interest; citing Clow v. Plummer, 85 Mich. 550.1</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently March 1906

2 state decisions

Relies on Clow v. Plummer · Mower v. Verplanke

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1895-05-21

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Grant, J.

¶1For a statement of the issue, see same case in 101 Mich. 209. A rehearing was granted upon the statement in the motion for rehearing that the point upon which the judgment was affirmed was not raised •in the'court below. '• The:point was expressly raised anÜ argued in the brief, for the appellees, and was-nóC mentioned in the brief for the appellant. We therefore assumed that the point whs raised upon the'trial. A re-examination of the record .shows that .it was n.ot, and therefore should not have been considered in the former decision. .

¶2•' The ground upon whiéh the court below excludéd the record of the probate of the will in the county of .Ottawa was that'the petitioner .was not interested in such' will, vyithin the meaning of How-¡Stat. § 58,06, which will, be found in the former opinion.-. The petitioner represented in his petition that he was interested “as a subsequent *400purchaser of the estate oí the deceased.” It was not necessary for him to set forth the proofs of his interest. This case is clearly within the reasoning of Clow v. Plummer, 85 Mich. 550. The petition was sufficient to give the probate court jurisdiction, and the record was therefore admissible in evidence.

¶3Judgment reversed, and a new trial ordered.

The other Justices concurred.
/105/mich/398 · .json · Public domain