Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

107 Ark. 21

Smith v. Carter

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided February 10, 1913

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1913-02-10

Petition for mandamus. STATEMENT OE EACTS. The petitioner asks a mandamus from this court to compel respondent, Judge of the Eighth Judicial Circuit, to cause the circuit clerk to reinstate on the common law docket case No. 1090, wherein petitioner was plaintiff and the Texas & Pacific Railway Company was defendant, and to compel the respondent, as circuit judge, to proceed to try said cause anew.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently September 1968

1 state decisions

Relies on Jonas Grossmayer · Automatic Weighing Co. v. Carter · Gilbert v. Shaver

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Petition denied · Decided 1913-02-10

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Wood, J.

¶1(after stating the facts). The respondent, the circuit judge of the Eighth Circuit, did not refuse to entertain petitioner’s motion to reinstate, but, on the contrary, heard the same, and entered a judgment refusing the prayer of the petition and dismissing it. The petitioner excepted to the ruling of the court, and he had his remedy, if the circuit court erred in its judgment, by appeal to this court, but he can not have this court review the judgment of the circuit court for error in that proceeding, and for relief against it by a writ of mandamus..

¶2“A writ of mandamus indeed can not be used to perform the office of an appeal or writ of error to review the action of an inferior court, but if the court, after sufficient service of the defendant, erroneously declines to take jurisdiction of a case or to enter judgment therein, a writ of mandamus lies to compel it to proceed to a determination of the case, except where the authority to issue a writ of mandamus has been taken away by statute.” In re Grossmayer, 177 U. S. 48. See also, Goings v. Mills, 1 Ark. 11; Gilbert v. Shaver, 91 Ark. 231, p. 238; Automatic Weighing Co. v. Carter, 95 Ark. 118-121.

¶3The petition will be denied.

/107/ark/21 · .json · Public domain