Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

107 Ky. 354

Rhodes v. Commonwealth

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided December 7, 1899

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1899-12-07

Case Cl — INDICTMENT FOR MISDEMEANOR APPEAL FROM HENDERSON CIRCUIT COURT. 1. The remarks of the Commonwealth’s Attorney were improper, and the appellee is entitled to a new trial on account of them. People y. Ahlen, 92 Cal., 282; Elliott’s Geni. Prac., sec. 692; State v. Bobbst, 32 S. W., 1151; Sinclair v. State, 32 S. W., 531; Hatch v. State, 8 Tex. App., 416; People v. Dane, 59 Mich., 550. 2.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently March 1931

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1899-12-07

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

JUDGE PAYNTER

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2The appellant, Rhodes, was tried under an indictment for maintaining a bawdy-house. On the trial of the case he sought to show that the title to the property was in *355another, and in support of that tendered a deed. The deed had never been delivered and accepted. In arguing the case before the jury, over the objection of the appellant, the Commonwealth’s attorney used language as follows, to-wit: “The business of the defendant, Rhodes, in this town is to rent and furnish bawdy-houses, and he makes his living by public bawdry and public shame. He is an old offender, he knows the law, he has been to the penitentiary, and you should not believe him under oath.”

¶3Under our Constitution a person accused of an offense is entitled to trial by jury, conducted according to the rules of law. The court should' only permit the jury to hear relevant and competent facts. The accused is entitled to fair treatment by the judge who presides over the court, and by the Commonwealth’s attorney, who is a sworn officer of the law. Jurors believe that Commonwealth’s attorneys are interested in the conviction of persons guilty of offenses, and their statements of necessity have great weight with them. A Commonwealth’s attorney, in arguing a case to the jury, should not be permitted to state facts which do not appear in the record, or be permitted to accuse a defendant of offenses for which he is not being tried. He charged that the appellant’s business was to rent and furnish bawdy-houses; that he made his living by public bawdry and public shame; that he is an old offender. The defendant was under trial for being guilty of maintaining a bawdy-house on a certain street in Henderson. It was not even competent on the trial of the case to prove that he rented and furnished other bawdy-houses, etc.

¶4We are of the opinion that the Commonwealth’s attorney greatly transcended his duties in making the charge which he did against the defendant, and for that reason the case is reversed.

/107/ky/354 · .json · Public domain