Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

108 Conn. 738

143 A 845

Longworth v. McGrath

Supreme Court of Connecticut

Decided July 5, 1928

Supreme Court of Connecticut · decided 1928-07-05

Relies on Hawkins v. Garford Trucking Co., Inc. · New England Iron Work's Co. v. Connecticut Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1928-07-05

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently December 1979

2 district · 5 state decisions

50192819301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1 The sole error pursued on the appeal is the inclusion in the verdict of the sum of $140 for the loss of use of the plaintiff’s automobile. The only evidence of loss of use was that of the plaintiff, who testified that the fair and reasonable rental value of a car such as the one injured per day was $10, exclusive of the cost of a driver and of gas and oil and taking into consideration the depreciation, that is, the wear and tear on it every day. Because plaintiff testified that he had never hired a car of this type, the defendant appellant Wihbey claims that his testimony upon this subject-matter was mere hearsay.

¶2 That conclusion does not at all follow. The defendant neither sought to develop the basis of plaintiff’s opinion or to offer evidence upon this point. He cannot now be permitted to make this claim, especially in view of the fact that the court refused to set aside the verdict.

¶3*739 The defendant further claims that plaintiff introduced no evidence to show how much should be allowed for depreciation. On cross-examination, counsel for the defendant explained to the witness that by depreciation he meant wear and tear and then inquired: “Were you taking that into consideration when you said $10 a day?” And he answered, “Yes, I am.” The most that the defendant could claim from this was that the expression was susceptible of an equivocal meaning. We think the jury and court had the right to accept the answer as reasonably intending to exclude the element of depreciation. The evidence was sufficient from which to find the measure of the loss of use to plaintiff of this car for the admitted period of two weeks within our established rule. Hawkins v. Garford Trucking Co., Inc., 96 Conn. 337, 114 Atl. 94; New England Iron Works Co. v. Connecticut Co., 98 Conn. 609, 120 Atl. 281.

¶4 There is no error.

/108/conn/738 · .json · Public domain