Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

108 F. 989

Docket No. 147.

The N. & W. No. 2

Second Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided May 10, 1901.)

Second Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1901-05-10

This eause comes here upon appeal from a decree of the district court, Eastern district of New York, holding both tug and tow responsible for a stranding on the north side of the main channel into the harbor of New York, and dividing the damages.

2 counsel of record

Opinion by (per_curiam) · Decided 1901-05-10

¶1Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Eastern District of New York. This eause comes here upon appeal from a decree of the district court, Eastern district of New York, holding both tug and tow responsible for a stranding on the north side of the main channel into the harbor of New York, and dividing the damages.

¶2Wilhelmus Mynderse, for claimant.

¶3H. (1. Ward, for libelant.

¶4Before WALLACE and LACOMBE, Circuit Judges.

¶5PER CURIAM.

¶6The testimony is most conflicting, and the contradictions of fact so sharp that it is absolutely impossible to harmonize them upon any theory. Nearly all the witnesses called by the libelant were examined by deposition. Nearly all those called by the claimant were before the district judge. We have not been able out of this mass of contradictions to satisfy ourselves that his ultimate conclusions should he reversed, although we may not concur in all his findings. The weight of evidence seems to indicate that the tow was not steered with the care and jjrompt attention to incipient sheers which the situation called for, and that the tug laid her course closer to the northern edge of the channel than she should have done, in view of the existing conditions. Decree affirmed, without interest or costs.

/108/f1d/989 · .json · Public domain