¶1This case presents no question of the evidence necessary to support a conviction, but merely of the sufficiency of the charge. The complaint alleges that the defendant at a certain time and place unlawfully kept intoxicating liquors with intent unlawfully to sell the same in this Commonwealth, he not being authorized to sell the same for any purpose under the provisions of the St. of 1869, e. 415, “or by any legal authority whatever.” It is in the form prescribed by statute, and clearly and sufficiently charges an unlawful keeping by the defendant, and that he intended to sell liquors of a kind which, and in a place where, the law did not allow him to sell. It need not more particularly describe the kind of liquors which he intended to sell, nor negative any of the various modes and contingencies in which it might be lawful for him to sell them. Sts. 1869, c. 415, § 66; 1870, e. 389, § 8. Commonwealth v. Gilland, 9 Gray, 3. Commonwealth v. Purtle, 11 Gray, 78. Commonwealth v. Dunn, 14 Gray, 401. Commonwealth v. Lynn, 107 Mass. 214. Commonwealth v. Bennett, ante, 27. Exceptions overruled.
108 Mass. 412
Commonwealth v. Grady
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Decided November 15, 1871
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1871-11-15
<p>A complaint on the St. of 1869, c. 415, § 36, with proper averments of time and place, that the defendant “unlawfully did keep intoxicating liquor with intent unlawfully to sell the same in this Commonwealth,” he “not being authorized to sell the same in this Commonwealth for any purpose ” under the St. of 1869, c. 415, “or by any legal authority whatever,” is sufficiently certain and precise, without specifying the kind of the intoxicating liquor, or further negativing any mode or contingency in which he might lawfully sell it, although the alleged time of the offence is after the passage of the Sts. of 1870, cc. 389, 390.</p>
Cited by 2 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently October 1881
1 state decisions
Relies on Commonwealth v. Lynn
Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know
Decided 1871-11-15
View the full empirical analysis of this case →