Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

108 Wis. 254

Ryan v. Philippi

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided December 7, 1900

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1900-12-07

Dioe, Circuit Judge. Appeal from an order refusing to set aside a judgment as to appellant, the judgment having been rendered against him and two other persons as partners. The order appealed from does not refer to the papers on which it was based, nor the returns of the clerk to this court show the papers upon which the motion was heard. The returns are three in number.

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently November 1905

4 state decisions

Relies on Glover v. Wells & Mulrooney Grain Co. · Tenney v. City of Madison · Hoffman & Billings Manufacturing Co. v. Burdick

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Appeal dismissed · Decided 1900-12-07

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*255The following opinion was filed October 30, 1900:

MaRshall, J.

¶2The appeal must be dismissed. Sec. 3050, Stats. 1898, requires the return, on appeal from an order, to contain the order appealed from and the original papers, or copies thereof, used by either party on the application therefor; and sec. 6, rule XT, of the circuit court rules, requires an order to refer to all records and papers used or read by either party upon the application therefor. The last requisite was not complied with, but that is not jurisdictional if it was not for the fact that the clerk’s certificate does not show that he has sent to this court the papers used upon the motion. The papers sent up being affected by both infirmities mentioned, it is impossible to tell what the order appealed from is based upon. That is jurisdictional,— so decided in Glover v. Wells & Mulrooney G. Co. 93 Wis. 13; Hoffman & Billings Mfg. Co. v. Burdick, 95 Wis. 342; Tenney v. Madison, 99 Wis. 539; Superior C. L. Co. v. Superior, 104 Wis. 463.

¶3By the Court.— The appeal is dismissed.

¶4A motion for a rehearing was denied December 1,1900.

/108/wis/254 · .json · Public domain