Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

11 Ga. 63

Duncan v. Bryan

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided January 15, 1852

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1852-01-15

Motion to dismiss a bill, in Dooly Superior Court. Decision by Judge Warren, November Term, 1851. Seaborn C. Biyan, as trustee for Mrs. Mary Wallace, filed a bill against George M. Duncan, her former trustee, alleging, that Wm.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1852-01-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently September 1926

4 state decisions

2018521860187018801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*65By the Court.

Lumpkin, J.

¶2delivering the opinion.

¶3William. Britton died in South Carolina, bequeathing to his niece, Mary Edwards, a negro woman by the name of Corboro. The following is the clause in the will of Britton, disposing of this property: “ I lend my niece, Mary Edwards, one negro girl and her increase, Corboro, during my niece’s natural life, and at her death, to the lawful issue of her body; and in case my niece Mary should die without issue or a minor, then it is my will and desire, that this negro girl, Corboro, and her issue, should revert to my niece, Nancy, and in like manner to the lawful issue of her body.”

¶4Mary Edwards, the legatee, afterwards intermarried with Richard Wallace, and removed to the State of Georgia. Wallace, the husband, being in debt, and his creditors having instituted proceedings to subject Corboro and her children to the payment of their claims, Mrs. Wallace, the wife, came into Court and applied to have James Holderness appointed her trustee, to-protect this property from her husband’s contracts. Holderness, some time thereafter, surrendered up the trust, and George M. Duncan, the defendant, with his consent, was substituted as his successor.

¶5And this bill is filed Ijy Seaborn C. Bryan, who has been appointed trustee, pendente lite, of Mrs. Wallace, to compel Duncan to account for this property and its proceeds. Duncan, by his solicitor, moved to dismiss the bill for want of equity, which motionjwas refused by the Court, and this refusal is assigned as error.

¶6The general doctrine is not disputed, that one who has accepted a trust and acted upon it, will not be allowed to repudiate it when called upon to account. But it is insisted that, under the will of Britton, Mrs. Wallace took no separate estate, but an estate for life or in fee, which was transmissible, and upon which the marital rights of Wallace, the husband, attached; that as to these slaves, she is not sui juris, and that Chancery cannot render a decree in her favor.

¶7We concede that this is the true construction of Britton’s will, *66and that if the right of Mrs. Wallace rested on this foundation alone, that it could not be sustained. But Duncan having acknowledged this to be separate property, and it having been adjudged to be such, by a Court of competent jurisdiction, whose decision remains unreversed; and Duncan having obtained possession of the negroes, under the order of the Court appointing him trustee, it is neither consistent with sound law nor good conscience, to permit him to deny the relationship, when summoned b^ that same Court, to account for his stewardship.

¶8By the order of the Court appointing him trustee, this is separate property, so far as he is concerned, and Mrs. Wallace is sui juris, as to this estate, in a controversy between her and her trustee. Should the rights of third persons intervene, either of Mr. Wallace, the husband, or of his creditors, who were no parties to this proceeding, the question would present a very different aspect.

¶9While it is admitted that Duncan cannot deny his character of trustee, it is argued that he holds the slaves in trust for the true owner, and not for Mrs. Wallace. The answer to this is, that Duncan was appointed trustee for the wife, and for nobody else; and that as yet, no otherparties are before the Court.

¶10Again, it is contended that the order appointing Duncan, was ex parte, and therefore, not binding. Grant this, notwithstanding the contrary appears by the record to be true, still, if Duncan came in afterwards and made himself a party to it by accepting the trust, as he did, it is such a ratification of the proceeding as would conclude him. In short, having consented to act as Mrs. Wallace’s trustee, he will be forever afterwards precluded from contesting the fact in any suit between themselves. The law forces no one to accept a gift, of an estate, whether made in trust or otherwise. It was competent for Mr. Duncan, to refuse both the estate of Mrs. Wallace and the office attached to it. But having once accepted the trust and got possession of the property, he cannot renounce or throw off the duties and responsibilities thus voluntarily incurred.

¶11We cannot discover any error in this case, and therefore affirm the judgment.

/11/ga/63 · .json · Public domain