Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

112 N.C. 652

Garrison v. Tinley

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided February 15, 1893

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1893-02-15

Civil aotior for the recovery of land, tried before Bynum, J., and a jury, at the Fall Term, 1891, of the Superior Court of IÍENDKRKON County. The complaint and answer were as follows: The plaintiff complains of the defendant and alleges— 1.

Decided 1893-02-15

MaoRae, J.

¶1(after stating the facts as above): There is no testimony to show that the land described in the petition is the same as that for the possession of which this action is brought, unless it be that the recitals in the deed from Rick-man, administrator, tp Justice are evidence to connect the two descriptions; and we know of no rule of evidence nor statute, as in the case of burned records (The Code, §69), to impart this extraordinary effect to said recitals, the same making no reference to the description in the petition. It follows that the record relied on as an estoppel may relate to an entirely different tract of land. Tliis renders it unnecessary for us to consider the interesting questions presented on the argument.

¶2Taking the evidence, as we must do, in the most favorable view for the plaintiff in which it could be considered, there was error in the intimation of his Honor. The judgment of nonsuit must be reversed and a new trial granted.

¶3New Trial.

/112/nc/652 · .json · Public domain