Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

113 Mass. 250

Cardoze v. Swift

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 15, 1873

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1873-10-15

Tort. The declaration was as follows: “ And the plaintiff says the defendant sold him a cow, for which the plaintiff paid him one hundred dollars, and to induce the plaintiff to buy said cow, the defendant falsely represented to the plaintiff that said cow was a good milker, was gentle and kind, and was gentle and kind while being milked, and could be milked anywhere.

Relies on Hall v. Corcoran

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1873-10-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 22 later decisions — most recently February 1942

1 federal appellate · 21 state decisions

5018731880189019001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, C. J.

¶1If the contract of sale was made and completed on the Lord’s day, it was unlawful, and neither party was entitled to sue the other, either on the contract itself, or for any deceit practised in procuring it. Robeson v. French, 12 Met. 24. Hall v. Corcoran, 107 Mass. 251, 253. Cranson v. Goss, Ib. 439. The only question in this case is of the effect of the defendant's omission to specify the illegality in his answer.

¶2*252In Jones v. Andover, 10 Allen, 18, where the plaintiff alleged that, while travelling, using due care, on a highway which the defendants were bound to keep in repair, he sustained injury from a defect therein, it was held that under an answer which merely denied all his allegations it might be shown that he was travelling in violation of the Lord’s Day Act. We need not consider how far the reasons of that decision apply to this action of tort for deceit, but may assume, as most favorable to the plaintiff, that his case stands like an action on a contract.

¶3In such an action, a defendant, who has not pleaded illegality in the contract sued on, has no right to offer evidence of such illegality, or even to avail himself of it when disclosed in the plaintiff’s testimony, if the court does not refuse to entertain the case. Granger v. Isley, 2 Gray, 521. Bradford v. Tinkham, 6 Gray, 494. Libby v. Downey, 5 Allen, 299. Goss v. Austin, 11 Allen, 525. But no waiver by the defendant, or consent of parties, can oblige a court of justice to try or enforce a claim which upon the plaintiff’s own showing has no foundation in law. The plaintiff has therefore no ground of exception to the instruction given to the jury. Exceptions overruled.

/113/mass/250 · .json · Public domain