Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

113 Mass. 348

Lamson v. Clarkson

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided November 15, 1873

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1873-11-15

<p>A lessee is not, by a covenant to pay rent, estopped, in an action for the rent, to show that the lessor’s estate ended before the rent accrued.</p>

Relies on Hilbourn v. Fogg

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1873-11-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 23 later decisions — most recently December 1971

1 federal appellate · 1 district · 20 state decisions — followed in 11 states

7018731880189019001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, C. J.

¶1The question presented by this case is whether a tenant, who has executed an indenture of lease for a year, and covenanted thereby to pay a certain rent quarterly, and has occupied the premises until the end of the term, is estopped to show that his landlord’s only title was an estate for the life of another, which expired during the term, and thereby to justify himself in not paying to the landlord rent subsequently accrued. And we are of opinion that he is not so estopped.

¶2So far as the estoppel of the tenant to deny-his landlord’s title is an estoppel in pais, it arises out of his having entered into possession under that title at the beginning of the lease; and he does not deny that the landlord had a title at that time, by alleging and proving that it has since expired. Hilbourn v. Fogg, 99 Mass. 11. Grundin v. Carter, Ib. 15.

¶3So far as it is an estoppel by deed, it arises out of the execution of the indenture; and some interest, as the tenant admits, having passed by the deed, he is not estopped to show what the quantity and duration of that interest was, and that it expired before the rent accrued, which the landlord now seeks to recover. Treport's case, 6 Co. 14 b, 15 a. Smalman v. Agburrow, 1 Rol. R. 441, 442 ad fin. and 3 Bulst. 272, 275. Brudnell v. Roberts, 2 Wils. 143. Blake v. Foster, 8 T. R. 487. Doe v. Seaton, 2 C., M. & R. 728, and Tyrwh. & Gr. 19. Langford v. Selmes, 3 K. & J. 220, 226. 2 Saund. 418, note. 1 Platt on Leases, 94. The tenant’s covenant is only to pay a certain sum as rent, and, in the words of Doderidge, J., in 3 Bulst. 274, “ if it be so that the estate be ended, the contract for the rent will end also, this being but quid pro quo, sc. the rent for the land.” Upon the termination of the landlord’s estate, the tenant became a tenant at suffer*350ance, and no longer liable for rent under the covenants in the indenture. Vin. Ab. Debt, B. pl. 4. Page v. Wight, 14 Allen, 132, 134.

¶4No adjudication inconsistent with these views was referred to in the learned arguments at the bar. In Morse v. Goddard, 13 Met. 177, in George v. Putney, 4 Cush. 351, and in many cases in other courts, cited for the plaintiff, the tenant, having been evicted by, or attorned in good faith to, one who had a paramount title, was held to be thereby excused from payment of subsequent rent, whether that title vested before or after the beginning of the lease; and no decision was made or required upon the question whether, without such eviction or attornment, he could have relied on the expiration of the landlord’s title during the term. In Binney v. Chapman, 5 Pick. 124, the tenant, after notice of the adverse title, had made a new agreement to continue to hqld of his landlord. Exceptions sustained.

/113/mass/348 · .json · Public domain