Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

113 N.C. 21

18 S.E 72

Mizell v. . Ruffin

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided September 5, 1893

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1893-09-05

Civil action for the recovery of damages for a breach of warrant}'', tried before Hoke, J., and a jury, at Spring Term, 1893, of the Superior Court of Bertie County. The plaintiff introduced in evidence a deed from one Iiollo-man to J. B. Burden, also a deed from Joseph Burden to J. B. Ruffin, the defendant, dated February, 1871, conveying to the said Ruffin, his heirs and assigns forever, a portion of his (the grantor’s) timber on Ahoskie and Loosing swamps.

Decided 1893-09-05

Clark, J.:

¶1 The deed from Burden to Ruffin conveyed “a portion of his cypress timber on Ahoskie and Loosing swamps.” This is void for uncertainty, for it does not appear what portion is conveyed. Harrison v. Hahn, 95 N. C., 28; Blakely v. Patrick (the “ buggy case”), 67 N. C., 40; Atkinson v. Graves, 91 N. C., 99; McDaniel v. Allen, 99 N. C , 135. Nor is this helped out or rendered more certain by the condition which immediately follows, that the grantor and his heirs “ may retain from this timber enough for his fai;m and building purposes.” The relative pronoun “this” refers to its antecedent, which is the “portion” which is attempted to be conveyed. But if the reservation was out of the whole body *24 of the timber, the “portion” conveyed would still remain indefinite. It maj or may not be that the grantor intended to convey all his timber, except that reserved, but it is clear that such is not the plain meaning of the words used, and the rules of legal construction will not admit of a surmise of the probable intent of the grantor contrary to the purport of his words. The subsequent deed given by Burden to Wynns is admitted to be sufficient in form.

¶2 There has been a breach of the warranty given by Ruffin to the plaintiffs, for which they can maintain their action. Whether the defendant is protected by the statute of limitations, or has other adequate matter of defence, is not now before us. Error.

/113/nc/21 · .json · Public domain