Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

115 Ind. 345

Syfers v. Bradley

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided April 24, 1888

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1888-04-24

<p>Chattel Mortgage. — Sale.—Purchase by Mortgagee. — Execution.—Instructions not to Levy. — Suspension of Lien. — Damages.—Where the mortgagee of chattels has become the purchaser thereof at a public sale duly made under a power contained in the mortgage, the levy afterwards of an execution in favor of judgment creditors of the mortgagor, the lien of which had been theretofore suspended by a direction to the officer not to levy, is without effect, and the mortgagee may recover from such creditors and officer damages sustained by him by the taking and withholding possession of the property.</p> <p>Same. — Achrmdedgment.—Recording.—An averment that a chattel mortgage was recorded in the proper recorder’s office carries with it the implication that it had been properly acknowledged and otherwise prepared for record.</p>

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently October 1916

5 state decisions

Relies on Carver v. Carver · Taylor v. City of Fort Wayne · Westerman v. Foster

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1888-04-24

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1On Petition for a Rehearing.

Niblack, C. J.

¶2As has been seen, the complaint alleged that Walker Brothers executed to the plaintiffs a chattel mortgage on their stock of groceries and other personal property to secure the debt therein described; that it also alleged that the plaintiffs in due time caused the mortgage to be recorded in the recorder’s office of Hancock county, the county in which Walker Brothers resided, and in which the mortgaged property was situate.

¶3The point was made at the hearing that the complaint was fatally defective in its failure to aver that the mortgage was properly acknowledged before it was recorded; but, regarding the point as wholly immaterial to the merits of the appeal, we did not make any distinct ruling upon it. In their petition for a rehearing the appellees have renewed the point with much earnestness and apparent confidence,,and insist that we shall now consider it.

¶4The presumptions are all in favor of a public officer having done his'duty in every matter concerning which he has taken official action.

¶5The allegation that the mortgage was recorded in' the proper recorder’s office, consequently carried with it the implication that the mortgage had been duly prepared for record before it was recorded. In legal contemplation, the entry of an unacknowledged deed or mortgage on the recorder’s books does not constitute a recording of the instrument. Taylor v. City of Fort Wayne, 47 Ind. 274; Westerman v. Foster, 57 Ind. 408 ; Carver v. Carver, 97 Ind. 497.

¶6The acknowledgment of a deed or mortgage has reference only to the proof of its execution and to its preparation for record, and forms no part of the instrument itself. Cray v. Ulrich, 8 Kans. 112.

Filed June 27, 1888.

¶7If the mortgage in question was not acknowledged before it was recorded, the objection can be made, and will regularly arise upon the evidence at the trial. If an acknowledgment can not be shown the record will be of no avail.

¶8Other questions are re-argued, but they have already received sufficient consideration.'

¶9The petition for a rehearing is overruled.

/115/ind/345 · .json · Public domain