Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

116 Mich. 261

Michigan Beef & Provision Co. v. Coll

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided March 15, 1898

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1898-03-15

Cross-appeals from Wayne; Haire, J., presiding. Judgment creditor’s bill by the Michigan Beef & Provision Company against John Coll and wife and the Wayne County Savings Bank. From a decree subjecting an undivided one-half interest in certain lands to the payment of complainant’s judgment, both parties appeal.

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““We may properly infer that all of Coil’s property is in this land, and that considerable was paid upon the contracts which he should have paid to his creditor, suit being then pending. This was not justified by the fact that he had outstanding contracts,. and we think should be no more beyond reach' than as though the entire title had passed to the wife, as said in Newlove v. Callaghan.””

quoted by 1 later decision, including Lemerise v. Robinson

Relies on Chandler v. Cheney · Speier v. Opfer · Newlove v. Callaghan

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1898-03-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently February 2005

1 federal appellate · 7 state decisions

30189819001910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Hooker, J.

¶1A judgment was rendered in January, 1896, for $857.60, including costs, in favor of the complainant, upon an account which commenced in May, 1893, against John Coll. Execution was returned unsatisfied, and the bill in this cause was filed to reach certain real estate in Detroit, held by Coll and his wife as joint *262tenants under a conveyance dated July 10, 1895, made in pursuance of certain land contracts dated in 1887 and 1891, respectively. To prove the case, the complainant called as a witness John Coll. His wife objected to his testifying against her. The circuit judge expressed the opinion that the objection was good as to her estate, but that the testimony should be received “against the husband’s portion ” of the estate. The difficulty is that the husband has no portion in such an estate that is separable from that of the wife. It is but one estate, and it is impossible to carve anything out of it during the joint lives, without affecting the interest of the wife. Vinton v. Beamer, 55 Mich. 559; Speier v. Opfer, 73 Mich. 39 (2 L. R. A. 345). See Chandler v. Cheney, 37 Ind. 391, 396. In Newlove v. Callaghan, 86 Mich. 297, 301, this court did not consider the testimony of the husband, taken under objection, and thus was not called upon to determine whether it was admissible or not. The case of Blanchard v. Moors, 85 Mich. 383, seems to be decisive of the question, if we are right in saying that her interest is necessarily affected by the testimony, of which we are convinced.

¶2It is necessary, therefore, for the complainant to establish its case by other evidence. This consists of the two contracts with payments indorsed, the deed, and the judgment, with execution returned unsatisfied. From these we find the lands were contracted before the debt was made, but that large payments were made after-wards. It is not shown who made them, or from whence the money came. In the case of Newlove v. Callaghan, supra,it is said that it is proper to presume that the husband made one-half of the payments, where no showing is made to the contrary. We may properly infer that all of Coil’s property is in this land, and that considerable was paid upon the contracts which he should have paid to his creditor, suit being then pending. This was not justified by the fact that he had outstanding contracts, and we think should be no more beyond reach than as though *263the entire title had passed to the wife, as said in Newlove v. Callaghan.

¶3The decree of the circuit court is affirmed, with costs.

The other Justices concurred.
/116/mich/261 · .json · Public domain