Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

117 Ill. App. 354

Grossman v. Davis

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided December 15, 1904

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1904-12-15

<p>1. Collection of judgment—when injunction does not lie to restrain. Injunction to restrain the collection of a justice’s judgment does not lie where it appears that the complainant knew of the entry of the judgment against him upon the day of its rendition, and in his bill does not set up fraud, accident or mistake which, prevented him from availing of his remedy by appeal. •</p> <p>2. Collection of judgment—bond essential to valid injunction restraining. It is error to enjoin the collection of a judgment without requiring the complainant to give bond as required by statute.</p> <p>8. Justice of peace—injunction does not lie against. A court of equity will not enjoin a justice of the peace concerning a matter over which he has jurisdiction.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““While the acts and doings of appellants as shown by the bill, which on this hearing must be taken as true, are unjust and inequitable, we are compelled to reverse the decretal order for the following reasons: First. Appellee had a complete remedy at law. He knew of the entry of this judgment by the justice of the peace the day it was rendered. He then had the indisputable right to appeal the case to the circuit court. It would there have been tried de novo. This he failed to do. No circumstance of fraud, accident, or mistake is set forth which prevented him from availing himself of this ample remedy. Such negligence bars relief in a court of equity.””

quoted by 1 later decision, including 252 Ill. App. 178 - Bachechi v. Inlander Paper Co.

Relies on City of Peoria v. Kidder · Garfield v. Douglass · Smith v. Powell

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed, · Decided 1904-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently May 1959

2 federal appellate · 3 state decisions

20190419101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Presiding Justice Ball

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2Appellee obtained a temporary restraining order upon a bill of complaint filed by him against appellants. They were thereby enjoined from prosecuting or collecting a certain judgment in the sum of $200 until the further order of the court. It is stated in the order that for good cause shown it shall issue without bond.

¶3While the acts and doings of appellants as shown by the bill, which on this hearing must be taken as true, are unjust and inequitable, we are compelled to reverse this decretal order for the following reasons :

¶4First. Appellee had a complete remedy at law. He knew of the entry of this judgment by the justice of the peace the day it was rendered. He then had the indisputable right to appeal the case to the Circuit Court. It would' there have been tried de novo. This he failed to do. No circumstance of fraud, accident or mistake is set forth which prevented him from availing himself of this ample remedy. Such negligence bars relief in a court of equity. Peoria v. Kidder, 26 Ill. 351; Smith v. Powell, 50 Ill. 21; Grampp v. McBrearty, 109 Ill. App. 277.

¶5Second. One of the appellants thus enjoined is the justice of the peace. It is elementary that a court of equity will not enjoin a justice of the peace concerning a matter over which he has jurisdiction. Eberhardt v. The Penn Co., 15 Ill. App. 543; Klinesmith v. Van Bramer, 104 Ill. App. 387. If a justice of the peace acts corruptly he can be made to answer civilly and criminalljL Garfield v. Douglass, 22 Ill. 100.

¶6Third. The injunctional order was allowed without bond. This action of the court is in the teeth of the statute. Sec. 8, ch. 69, R. S., reads as follows: “ Before an injunction shall issue to enjoin a judgment, the complainant shall give bond to the plaintiff therein, in double the amount of such judgment, with sufficient surety, approved by the court, judge, or master, conditioned for the payment of all moneys and costs due to the plaintiff in the judgment, and such damages as may be awarded against the complainant in case the injunction is dissolved.”

¶7The decree of the Circuit Court is reversed.

¶8Reversed.

/117/illapp/354 · .json · Public domain