Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

117 N.C. 264

23 S.E 177

Curran v. . Kerchner

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided September 5, 1895

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1895-09-05

Civil aotioN, heard at September Term, 1895, of New Hanover Superior Court, before Oreene, J., on amotion for judgment by default final for want of answer to the first of two causes of action arising on two notes set out in the complaint, an answer having been filed to the second cause of action. The motion was refused and the plaintiff appealed. The facts are sufficiently stated in the opinion of Associate Justice Lurches. '

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1917

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1895-09-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Furches, J. :

¶1 This is an action to recover money, brought on two notes, one for two thousand dollars and the other *265 for five thousand dollars — each note set out and alleged as different causes of action — first cause and second cause of action.

¶2 This action was returnable to September term, 1895, of New HaNOvee Superior Court, at which term the plaintiff filed a verified complaint, and defendant answered as to the $5,000 note set out as the second cause of action but made no answer whatever to the $2,000 note set out as the first cause of action.

¶3 Upon this state of pleadings plaintiff moved for judgment on the $2,000 note and the court denied this motion and refused to grant the judgment as asked. In this there was error." Sections 382 and 385 of The Oocle.

¶4 There being no answer as to the $2,000 note the couit should have given the plaintiff judgment on this note and retained the $5,000 note for trial upon the issues raised by the pleadings. Parker v. Bledsoe, 87 N. C., 221. This refusal to allow plaintiff’s motion and to give judgment on the $2,000 note was the denial of a substantial right and may be appealed from and reviewed by this Court. Griffin v. Light Co., 111 N. C., 434.

¶5 There is Error.

/117/nc/264 · .json · Public domain