Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

118 A.D. 566

McDonald v. Vito

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · decided 1907-03-06

Appeal 'by the defendants, Donato Be Yito and another, from a judgment of the County Court of Oneida county in favor of the plaintiff, entered in the office of the cleric of .said, county on the 6th day of June, 1906, upon the verdict of a jury rendered by direction of the court, and also from an order bearing date the 5th day of June, 1906, and entered in said clerk’s office, directing the verdict in favor of the plaintiff.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1924

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1907-03-06

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Kruse, J.:

¶1While the evidence was undisputed that the plaintiff rendered legal services for the defendants at their request, for which the plaintiff, was entitled to recover what they were reasonably worth, *567if the testimony of the plaintiff is to be taken as true, yet even in that view, the value of the services was a question of fact for the jury; but beyond that the testimony on behalf of the defendants tended to prove that the services were rendered in certain actions under a special contract for which the plaintiff was to receive twenty-five per cent of the recovery. If this agreement was made, as claimed on behalf of the defendants, then the plaintiff was not entitled to recover what the services were reasonably worth, but was necessarily limited by the terms of his contract to twenty-five per cent of the recovery. Itris true that the defendants refused to attend the trial of the actions, but that was after the plaintiff had refused to proceed under the contract as claimed by the defendants, and they had refused to proceed with the actions because of the plaintiff’s repudiation of the contract as claimed by them. If the defendants were right in their contention, they were under no obligation to continue the services of the plaintiff, and had incurred no liability for what he had done.

¶2We are clearly of the •opinion that questions of fact were presented by the evidence which required the case to he submitted to the jury, and it was error to direct a verdict for the plaintiff.

¶3The judgment and order should be reversed and a new trial granted, with costs to the appellants to abide the event.

¶4All concurred,

¶5. Judgment and order reversed and new trial ordered, with costs to the appellants to abide the event.

/118/ad/566 · .json · Public domain