Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

118 Cal. 330

Hagen v. Beth

California Supreme Court

Decided September 22, 1897

California Supreme Court · decided 1897-09-22

<p>Mandatoby Injunction—Removal op Teams Signs Pendente Lite.—The granting of a mandatory injunction pending the trial of an action, and before the rights of the parties in the subject matter which the injunction is designed to effect have been definitively ascertained, is not permitted except in extreme cases where the right thereto is clearly established, and it appears that irreparable injury will flow from the refusal; and in an action to enjoin the use of a trade name a mandatory injunction to compel the removal of trade signs by the defendants pendente lite is erroneous, where the ultimate rights of the parties cannot be determined in advance of the trial of the action.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““The granting of a mandatory injunction pending the trial, and before the rights of the parties in the subject matter which the injunction is designed to affect have been definitely ascertained by the chancellor, is not permitted except in extreme cases where the right thereto is clearly established and it appears that irreparable injury will flow from its refusal.” (See 43 C.J.S. 412-413; 28 Am.Jur. 214.) The application of this rule to the facts of this case is all that is necessary to support our order.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Allen v. Hotel & Restaurant Employees' International Alliance

Relies on Schwarz v. Superior Court · Gardner v. Stroever

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1897-09-22

How this case has been cited

Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently December 2012

12 state decisions

401897190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

VAN FLEET, J.

¶1Appeal from an order granting a preliminary injunction.

¶2The nature of the present action and the terms of the order appealed from will be found sufficiently stated in Schwarz v. Superior Court, 111 Cal. 106, where the same order was under consideration upon certiorari to review the action of the court below in attempting to punish these appellants for contempt for an al*331leged violation of its terms. It was there held that the order, in so far as it directed and required the removal of the obnoxious signs, was mandatory in character.

¶3To the extent that the injunction is mandatory it was erroneously granted. The granting of a mandatory injunction pending the trial,"and before the rights of the parties in the subject matter which the injunction is designed to affect have been definitively ascertained by the chancellor, is not permitted except in extreme cases where the right thereto is clearly established and it appears that irreparable injury will flow from its refusal. (High on Injunctions, sec. 2; Gardner v. Stroever, 81 Cal. 148.)

¶4The showing in the record before us is not such as to entitle respondents to have the objectionable signs removed pending the final determination of the rights of the parties in the disputed name. It cannot be determined therefrom what the final judgment as to those rights may or should be upon a trial of the action.

¶5As to the merely preventive features of the injunction, we cannot say that the showing was insufficient to invoke the discretionary power of the court, and the order in that respect should stand.

¶6The other questions discussed are such as will more appropriately arise upon a trial on the merits.

¶7The order is reversed, with directions to the court below to modify its injunction by strildng therefrom the requirement for the removal of the signs.

Garoutte, J., and Harrison, J., concurred.
/118/cal/330 · .json · Public domain